Pages

Friday, 6 March 2009

Andrew Marr cops out

The BBC heavyweight presenter and writer Andrew Marr, in last night’s first programme (called “Body and Soul”) of his BBC2 television series Darwin’s Dangerous Idea, copped out in the last few minutes.

In an otherwise excellent programme the implications for religions of the publication of On the Origin of Species was dismissed nonchalantly by saying that the Anglican and Roman Catholic churches had now come to terms with evolution by natural selection.

The extent to which the churches, and indeed other religions, have done this is largely by ignoring the implications altogether. The only theology that can accept evolution by natural selection is that of Epicurus. Only his gods escape untouched by scientific facts.

Andrew Marr let his audience down by failing to explain that science and religion are incompatible because of the theology that each religion has, and that it is necessary to choose between science and religion.

No comments:

Post a Comment

We welcome lively and challenging comments. However, please try to stay on topic, be polite and do not use abusive, racist or sexist language, and do not incite your readers to violence or other antisocial behaviour, or your comment will be deleted. This isn't censorship: it's a case of staying within the bounds of decency and having an eye to the law, although we realise the law will be different in different countries.

We do not bar anonymous comments at the moment, but we would prefer that those commenting play fair and use their name or at least a regular nom de plume. It does show a confidence in your convictions. We know, too, that it's easy to use a false name and be effectively anonymous, but, again, we appeal to your sense of good practice. Even a wacky nom de plume is better, since at least readers will come to know that contributor and maybe remember her or his previous comments.

Blatant commercial advertising will be removed.

Comments should not be construed as necessarily the policy or opinion of the Pink Triangle Trust.

Note: only a member of this blog may post a comment.